PART 2: The Marshal and the Five Women of Red-Rock Country – 052
Kane kept the Sharps rifle leveled at my chest while dawn slowly thinned the darkness above the canyon walls.
Her hands were steady, which troubled me considerably more than if they had been shaking.
A nervous person might make a mistake.
Kane did not look like a woman who made many mistakes.
I remained on my back with my palms open beside me while the cold desert sand pressed through my shirt.
“You said you found that among the rocks,” I said.
“I did.”
“And you expect me to believe rifles simply grow here?”
Dashka gave the faintest smile from where she stood near the spring.
“Only in good soil.”
Isha covered a laugh with a cough.
Kane did not laugh.
Tavana sat exactly where I had last seen her, her wrists still cuffed, her expression calm enough to make me wonder whether I had ever actually been in charge of anything since cutting those women down from the cottonwood.
Yon knelt beside a small bundle of dried plants she had apparently gathered before sunrise.
None of them seemed frightened.
That realization settled into me harder than the rifle barrel ever could.
They had been hanging from a tree when I found them.
They had been exhausted, thirsty, bleeding at the wrists, and marked as wanted killers by a federal reward notice.
Yet somewhere between the cottonwood and this hidden spring, the truth had changed shape.
Or perhaps it had always been a different shape, and I was only now beginning to see it.
“Marshal,” Tavana said quietly, “Kane is not going to shoot you.”
Kane glanced toward her.
“You might have told him sooner.”
“I wanted to know what he would do.”
“What was I supposed to do?” I asked.
Tavana’s eyes settled on mine.
“Exactly what you did.”
“And what was that?”
“Think before reaching for your gun.”
That answer irritated me because it was true.
My Winchester lay a few feet away beside my saddle blanket.
My revolver was still holstered beneath my coat.
The derringer inside my boot remained secret, or so I hoped.
Kane finally lowered the Sharps.
“Sit up.”
I did so slowly.
The muscles in my back complained.
“Now perhaps somebody can explain why five women accused of murder have rifles hidden in the wilderness.”
“Three rifles,” Dashka corrected.
I stared at her.
“Three?”
“One north of here, one near the old mesquite wash, and Kane’s rifle.”
“You have ammunition?”
“Enough.”
I looked from one face to another.
“You have horses?”
“No,” Isha said.
“Supplies?”
“Some.”
“Friends?”
Nobody answered.
That silence told me more than an answer would have.
Tavana lifted her cuffed hands.
“You are asking the wrong questions.”
“Then give me the right ones.”
“You should ask why a dead whiskey drinker was guarding five women who supposedly murdered two armed freight men.”
I had already asked myself that.
I simply had not liked any of the answers.
Kane handed the Sharps to Dashka and walked toward the spring.
Only when her back was turned did I allow myself to breathe normally.
I rose and brushed sand from my clothes.
“Why didn’t you use the hidden rifles yesterday?”
“Because we could not reach them while tied to a tree,” Isha replied.
“I meant before that.”
Isha’s expression hardened.
Tavana answered before the younger woman could.
“Because we were not armed when the men took us.”
“What men?”
“The same men who put the reward notice in your pocket without ever meeting you.”
I looked down at the folded paper protruding from my coat.
“That notice came from the territorial marshal’s office.”
“No,” Tavana said.
Her certainty bothered me.
I pulled it free and held it up.
“It carries the seal.”
“It carries a seal.”
I examined the printed notice again.
I had read it twice the day before, but exhaustion and heat had left little room for careful inspection.
The territorial emblem appeared ordinary.
The typeface looked right.
The signature at the bottom belonged to Acting Deputy Commissioner Horace Bell, a name I recognized from correspondence but had never personally met.
Tavana extended her hands.
“May I?”
I hesitated.
Then I passed her the notice.
She studied the page.
Instead of examining the seal, she smelled the paper.
Isha smiled at my confusion.
“You people write more than you notice.”
Tavana rubbed the corner of the sheet between two fingers.
“This was printed recently.”
“It is dated six days ago.”
“I mean recently as in yesterday or the day before.”
“How could you possibly know that?”
“Because the ink still smells of linseed.”
I took the page back and sniffed it.
All I smelled was paper, sweat, and desert dust.
Tavana watched me try.
“You have spent years around horses and gun oil.”
“And you haven’t?”
“My father printed church notices when I was a girl.”
That was the first piece of her past she had offered voluntarily.
I filed it away.
“So somebody printed counterfeit federal notices.”
“Several,” she said.
“How many?”
“We found nine.”
That made me look sharply at her.
“Where?”
“At the Pickering wagons.”
For several seconds, the only sound came from the spring trickling over stone.
“You were there.”
“Yes.”
“When?”
“Before the bodies were found.”
My hand moved instinctively toward my revolver.
Tavana’s gaze followed it.
I stopped.
“Tell me everything.”
She looked toward Kane, Dashka, Yon, and Isha.
Something passed among them without words.
Then Tavana nodded.
“We were traveling south from a trading camp near the Verde country.”
“Why?”
“To find a man named Elias Rowe.”
I knew the name.
Most lawmen in Arizona did.
Elias Rowe had once served as an Army scout and interpreter before becoming a guide, trader, and occasional nuisance to every territorial official who disliked being contradicted.
“He vanished two months ago,” Tavana continued.
“He sent us a letter before he disappeared.”
“What did it say?”
“That men were using false trails to turn settlers against Apache families and to frighten freight companies away from certain roads.”
The scattered moccasin prints beside the Pickering bodies flashed through my mind.
Too clean.
Too numerous.
Too conveniently placed.
“Why would anyone want freight companies avoiding those roads?”
“We did not know.”
“And now?”
Tavana looked at Dashka.
Dashka walked toward the rocks and removed a narrow leather pouch from a crack I would never have noticed.
Inside were three pieces of folded paper.
She gave them to me.
The first was a rough map.
The second was a list of dates and wagon companies.
The third contained nothing but numbers.
“What am I looking at?”
“Routes,” Tavana said.
I studied the map.
A dozen freight trails were marked.
Several had small crosses beside them.
I recognized two places where robberies had occurred during the past year.
One cross marked the Pickering attack.
Another marked the site where a mail coach had disappeared the previous winter.
A line had been drawn through each location toward a narrow corridor between the Black Mesa country and the southern mining settlements.
“What is this?”
“A road somebody wants abandoned.”
I looked at the column of numbers.
“Money?”
“Perhaps.”
“You don’t know?”
“No.”
“Then why were you at the Pickering wagons?”
“Because Elias told us to watch the road.”
“And you arrived after the attack?”
“During it.”
That answer brought all of us to stillness.
I lowered the papers.
“You saw who killed the brothers.”
“We saw men leaving,” Tavana said.
“How many?”
“Seven.”
“Cle Dupri?”
Kane turned from the spring.
“Yes.”
The name felt like a door opening.
For three weeks I had chased traces of Cle Dupri through country so dry even buzzards seemed reluctant to cross it.
Dupri had been blamed for robberies, cattle thefts, and two stagecoach attacks, but he had always managed to remain one horizon beyond the law.
“You saw Dupri at the wagons?”
“We saw his face.”
“Why didn’t you report it?”
Isha laughed without humor.
“To whom?”
“To any marshal.”
“Like you?”
“Yes.”
Her eyes dropped to the handcuffs still locked around Tavana’s wrists.
The answer lodged in my throat.
Tavana spared me from making an excuse.
“We tried.”
She told me they had ridden to a small settlement called Copper Run two days after the murders.
There they had found a deputy named Silas Cobb.
I knew Cobb only slightly.
He worked out of Tucson when he worked at all.
According to Tavana, he listened to their account, asked to see Elias Rowe’s letter, and told them to remain in town while he contacted the territorial office.
That night, somebody searched their room.
By morning, Cobb had disappeared.
So had Tavana’s letter.
Three days later, the reward notices appeared.
“And yesterday?” I asked.
“Men intercepted us near the wash,” Kane said.
“How many?”
“Four.”
“They took five of you without a fight?”
“We thought one of them was Cobb,” Yon said softly.
It was the first time I had heard her speak more than a few words.
Her voice possessed the calm quality I had noticed in her eyes.
“He called to us from behind a wagon,” she continued.
“We approached because we believed he needed help.”
“Was it Cobb?”
“No.”
“They knew his name?”
“They knew many things.”
A chill worked through me despite the rising sun.
“Why hang you from a tree and leave one man behind?”
“They were waiting,” Tavana said.
“For what?”
“For someone to find us.”
I looked toward the ridge where the shooter had died.
The dead man had not been guarding prisoners.
He had been guarding bait.
“Me?”
“Perhaps not you specifically.”
“A lawman.”
“Yes.”
I unfolded the reward notice again.
If a marshal found five wanted women tied to a tree, there were only a few likely outcomes.
He could arrest them.
He could be shot by the hidden rifleman.
Or he could shoot back, kill the guard, and carry five supposed murderers toward the nearest federal office.
Either way, the story would spread.
Five Apache women responsible for the Pickering killings.
Case closed.
Dupri disappeared.
The false trails remained unexplained.
And nobody asked why freight routes were being abandoned.
“What happened to the other three men who captured you?”
“They rode east,” Dashka said.
“When?”
“Before sunset.”
“Toward what?”
She looked at the map in my hand.
“Copper Run.”
The same settlement where Deputy Cobb had vanished.
I began pacing.
My training told me to return the women to federal custody.
My instincts told me doing that without understanding who had issued the warrant might place all five directly into the hands of whoever had created this scheme.
Tavana watched me struggle with it.
“You like rules,” she said.
“I like knowing which side of a jail door people belong on.”
“That is not the same thing.”
“It usually is.”
“And today?”
I looked at the rawhide wounds around her wrists.
“Today is complicated.”
I removed the key from my pocket.
Tavana’s expression changed for the first time.
Not relief.
Surprise.
I unlocked the cuffs.
Kane turned fully toward me.
Isha’s eyebrows rose.
Tavana rubbed her wrists but said nothing.
“This does not mean you’re free to leave,” I said.
Isha opened her mouth.
I pointed at her.
“Not one word.”
She closed it, although the smile remained.
“You’re still named on a federal warrant,” I continued.
“But until I know whether the warrant is real, I’m treating all five of you as material witnesses.”
“Material witnesses who can walk away?” Kane asked.
“No.”
“Then we are prisoners.”
“You’re witnesses with an unusually irritating marshal following you.”
Isha nodded thoughtfully.
“That sounds worse.”
This time even Yon smiled.
The moment eased something between us, though only slightly.
I gathered my gear and checked what remained after the packhorse had been killed.
Food for perhaps three days if rationed carefully.
One surviving canteen.
A bedroll.
A small medical pouch.
Ammunition.
Two horses for six people.
Dashka had dried meat hidden nearby.
Kane knew of another spring half a day’s travel east.
Tavana possessed information.
I possessed a badge.
None of us alone had enough to reach the truth.
Together, we might.
“Copper Run,” I said.
Tavana shook her head.
“No.”
“You just said the men went there.”
“And that is why we should not.”
“It’s where Cobb disappeared.”
“Exactly.”
“Then it’s where our answers are.”
“Or where someone expects us.”
“That too.”
Kane studied me with something that might have been reluctant approval.
“Your plans are poor.”
“I’ve survived most of them.”
“Most?”
I mounted my horse.
“That’s the comforting part.”
We traveled east through broken country where red cliffs folded into narrow washes and sage clung stubbornly to gravel.
Isha rode behind Yon for part of the morning while the rest of us walked.
Around noon, Dashka stopped abruptly.
She crouched beside an almost invisible depression in the trail.
“What?”
“Horse.”
“I can see that.”
“One horse.”
“How long ago?”
“Hours.”
She moved ten feet farther and examined another print.
“Same horse.”
“Following us?”
“No.”
“Then what?”
“Circling.”
I looked toward the high ground.
Nothing moved.
Kane had retrieved another hidden rifle before we left the spring, and she now carried it wrapped in a blanket to keep it from catching the sun.
“Scout?” I asked.
“Maybe,” Dashka said.
Tavana stared toward the east.
“No.”
Something in her voice made me turn.
“What is it?”
She pointed toward a dark shape barely visible beneath a line of cottonwoods.
At first I thought it was a rock.
Then the shape moved.
A horse.
Saddled.
Waiting.
We approached carefully.
No rider appeared.
The animal was an old gray gelding, lathered from hard travel but otherwise sound.
A leather dispatch bag hung from the saddle.
I recognized the federal stamp before I touched it.
“Marshal’s horse,” I said.
Tavana’s eyes narrowed.
“Cobb?”
I opened the bag.
Inside were two official envelopes, a tobacco pouch, a small notebook, and a deputy’s identification papers.
The name read SILAS COBB.
Isha whispered something under her breath.
“Where is he?” Yon asked.
I searched the nearby ground.
Dashka found the answer first.
Not a body.
Footprints.
One man had dismounted beneath the cottonwoods sometime during the night.
He had then walked deliberately north.
“He left the horse?” I asked.
Dashka nodded.
“Why?”
Tavana picked up the notebook.
Most of its pages had been torn out.
Only the final three remained.
The first contained several names.
The second showed a crude drawing of the territorial seal.
The third carried a single sentence written in hurried pencil.
I read it aloud.
“Boon Haleran is not to be trusted.”
No one spoke.
I read the words again.
My own name looked strangely foreign on the page.
Kane slowly shifted her rifle.
Isha stopped smiling.
Yon looked from the notebook to me.
Tavana alone remained unreadable.
“You said you barely knew Cobb,” she said.
“I did.”
“He knew you.”
“Apparently.”
“Why would a federal deputy write that?”
“I don’t know.”
Tavana stepped closer.
“Marshal, somebody issued a false warrant.”
“I know.”
“Somebody planted a dead gunman beside us.”
“I know.”
“Somebody used Apache tracks to disguise murder.”
“I know.”
“And now a missing federal officer has written your name inside the same mystery.”
She held out Cobb’s notebook.
The words stared back at me.
Boon Haleran is not to be trusted.
I had spent three weeks believing I was hunting Cle Dupri.
For the first time, I wondered whether somebody else had spent those same three weeks hunting me.
**–END OF PART 2–CLICK “NEXT” AT THE BOTTOM OF THE PAGE TO CONTINUE READING**
✓ S. Gary Kenneth
Kane kept the Sharps rifle leveled at my chest while dawn slowly thinned the darkness above the canyon walls. Her hands were steady, which troubled me considerably more than if they had been shaking….