PART 4: The Marshal and the Five Women of Red-Rock Country – 052
There are facts a man rejects because they are impossible, and there are facts he rejects because accepting them would require him to become someone else.
For me, Abigail belonged to the second kind.
I left the others inside Mercy Well and walked into the darkness.
The moon hung above the ridges, turning the desert into a pale country of shadow and silver.
I walked until the ruined station was little more than a shape behind me.
Then I stopped.
Four years earlier, I had received a telegram in Tucson telling me that my wife had died while traveling east.
There had been a stage accident outside Santa Fe.
The body had been badly burned.
A wedding ring had been recovered.
Her traveling trunk had carried her initials.
A priest had written to me.
I had arrived two days later and found a coffin already sealed.
I had asked to see her.
They told me I should remember her as she had been.
I had been thirty-one and numb with grief.
I had accepted that advice.
For four years, the fact had never troubled me.
Now it terrified me.
Because grief had persuaded me not to ask the simplest question a lawman should have asked.
Had anyone actually seen Abigail’s face?
Footsteps approached behind me.
I knew they belonged to Tavana before she spoke.
“You should not wander alone.”
“I have a gun.”
“So do foolish men.”
“I assume that was meant kindly.”
“It was.”
She stopped several feet away.
For once she did not press me with questions.
That made speaking easier.
“Abigail hated Arizona.”
Tavana waited.
“She said the desert made everything too visible.”
“What did she mean?”
“I never knew.”
“Perhaps she did.”
I gave a bitter laugh.
“That sounds like something she would say.”
I told Tavana about my marriage.
Not all of it.
Some memories still belonged only to the people who had lived them.
But enough.
Abigail had been a schoolteacher when we met in New Mexico.
She read newspapers from cities she had never visited and argued about politics with strangers in hotel dining rooms.
She believed law mattered but distrusted institutions that confused authority with virtue.
That had caused more than one argument between us.
“You were a marshal then?” Tavana asked.
“Deputy.”
“And she disliked it?”
“She disliked what it made me certain of.”
Tavana almost smiled.
“I would have liked her.”
“You would have exhausted each other.”
“That is not the same as dislike.”
When we returned to the station, Kane was repairing a torn saddle strap.
Yon had brewed a mild tea from desert herbs.
Isha had fallen asleep against a wall with her head on Dashka’s shoulder.
For the first time since the cottonwood, the five women did not look like suspects, witnesses, or people caught inside a conspiracy.
They looked like a family at the end of a long day.
I envied them.
The next morning we examined Emmett’s papers again.
A small notation appeared beside Abigail’s name.
S.L., room 7.
I knew one place in the region that fit.
“The Silver Lantern.”
Tavana looked at me.
“In Copper Run?”
“Yes.”
I had stayed there once.
It was a respectable boardinghouse on the north end of town, owned by a widow named Esther Bellamy.
“If Abigail used that room,” I said, “someone there may remember her.”
Kane tightened the repaired strap.
“And someone there may remember you.”
“That too.”
We decided not to enter Copper Run together.
Five women matching a reward notice beside a federal marshal would attract attention before we reached the first building.
Instead, Yon and Dashka would circle south and wait near an old irrigation ditch.
Kane and Isha would remain with the horses in a stand of cottonwoods west of town.
Tavana would go with me.
“Why Tavana?” Isha asked.
“Because she notices things.”
“I notice things.”
“You announce them.”
“That can be useful.”
“Not today.”
We reached Copper Run shortly after noon.
The settlement consisted of two dusty streets, perhaps forty buildings, a freight yard, a blacksmith, three saloons, and the kind of church whose white paint had surrendered years ago.
Nothing looked unusual.
That bothered me.
Places hiding secrets ought to have the decency to appear sinister.
Copper Run merely looked tired.
Tavana had exchanged her distinctive garment for a plain brown dress found among supplies at Mercy Well.
She wore a hat low over her face.
From a distance, nobody would match her to the reward notice.
We entered the Silver Lantern separately.
Esther Bellamy stood behind the desk sorting letters.
She recognized me immediately.
“Marshal Haleran.”
“Mrs. Bellamy.”
“Been a long while.”
“Not long enough for your coffee to improve, I hope.”
She laughed.
“You complained through four cups last time.”
“I was conducting an investigation.”
“You were conducting a refill.”
The familiarity reassured me.
Then her eyes moved to Tavana.
I introduced her as Miss Rowan, which was the first name that came into my mind.
Tavana’s expression suggested she considered my talent for aliases disappointing.
I asked for room seven.
Mrs. Bellamy stopped smiling.
“Occupied.”
“By whom?”
“A traveler.”
“Name?”
“You know I don’t give names to marshals without cause.”
“Good.”
She studied me.
“That is a strange response.”
“It means I still trust your judgment.”
That softened her.
I placed Emmett Pickering’s letter on the desk, covering everything except Abigail’s name and the notation.
Mrs. Bellamy looked down.
Her face lost color.
“Where did you get this?”
“Was she here?”
The widow looked toward the staircase.
That was answer enough.
My heart began hammering.
“Esther.”
“She told me not to tell you.”
The room seemed to tilt.
“When?”
Mrs. Bellamy swallowed.
“Four months ago.”
Tavana remained silent beside me.
“Abigail was here four months ago?”
“Yes.”
“You saw her?”
“Yes.”
“You are certain?”
“I knew your wife.”
“Why didn’t you send word?”
“Because she begged me not to.”
Anger rose first.
Then relief.
Then something more painful than either.
“What room?”
Mrs. Bellamy hesitated.
“Seven.”
I moved toward the stairs.
She caught my sleeve.
“She isn’t there now.”
I stopped.
“Where is she?”
“I don’t know.”
“Who does?”
“She left instructions.”
“For me?”
“For nobody unless Emmett Pickering came.”
“Emmett is dead.”
“I heard.”
“Then the instructions belong to me.”
Mrs. Bellamy looked at Tavana.
“No.”
She lowered her voice.
“They belong to her.”
Tavana blinked.
“To me?”
“Are you Tavana?”
Neither of us answered.
Mrs. Bellamy sighed.
“She described you.”
That changed everything again.
We went upstairs.
Room seven was small and neat.
A narrow bed stood beneath the window.
A pitcher rested beside a washbasin.
Nothing suggested anyone had occupied it recently.
Mrs. Bellamy opened the bottom drawer of the dresser and removed a sewing box.
Inside, beneath spools of thread, lay an envelope.
Tavana’s name was written across the front.
She opened it slowly.
I wanted to demand the letter.
Instead I waited.
Her eyes moved down the page.
Then she handed it to me.
The handwriting struck me like a physical blow.
Abigail’s hand.
I knew the sweep of the capital letters, the narrow spacing, the way she crossed every T slightly too high.
Boon will want answers before he has learned the right questions.
I almost laughed despite myself.
That was Abigail.
The letter explained that she had discovered evidence linking Voss to stolen military supplies four years earlier.
Cobb had approached her secretly.
He feared Bell and Judge Creed were protecting Voss.
Abigail intended to bring the evidence east.
Before she could, somebody attempted to kill her by arranging the stage accident.
Another passenger died.
The body was mistakenly identified as Abigail because her trunk and ring were found among the wreckage.
“She lost her ring?” Tavana asked.
I remembered.
Abigail often removed it while writing because the stone caught against the desk.
“Someone planted it.”
“Or she left it deliberately.”
I looked at the letter.
Abigail wrote that after the accident she realized Voss believed her dead.
She decided remaining dead offered protection.
She began working quietly with Elias Rowe.
They spent years collecting evidence.
Years.
While I mourned her.
While I stood at a grave.
While I returned each anniversary to place flowers beside a woman who was not there.
Anger tightened my chest.
Yet beneath the anger lived another truth I could not deny.
She had survived.
I kept reading.
Abigail apologized.
Not for hiding.
For deciding on my behalf that ignorance would keep me safe.
She had intended to come back once Voss’s network could be exposed.
Then Elias vanished.
Cobb became frightened.
Emmett Pickering changed sides.
Everything accelerated.
The final paragraph was addressed to Tavana.
If Boon is with you, he has finally reached the place I feared he would reach.
Do not let him follow me unless he understands this clearly: Voss is not the center of what is happening.
He is only the man who profits from it.
Ask Boon what happened to the rifles he recovered last year.
I lowered the paper.
“The stolen rifles.”
Tavana nodded.
“You said the evidence disappeared.”
“Yes.”
“Where were the rifles going?”
I thought back to the arrest.
Voss’s men had been carrying twelve new Springfield rifles in crates marked as agricultural machinery.
I had assumed they were stolen for resale.
But one detail returned now.
The serial numbers had been filed from only half the weapons.
“Some were government issue.”
“And the others?”
“I never checked.”
“Why?”
“Because Cobb took custody before I could.”
Tavana moved to the window.
“Then perhaps they were not stolen.”
“Perhaps they were being delivered.”
“To whom?”
A knock sounded downstairs.
Mrs. Bellamy froze.
Voices followed.
One belonged to a man.
Calm.
Official.
“Federal business.”
I moved toward the door.
Mrs. Bellamy caught my arm.
“That is Horace Bell.”
I had never met the acting deputy commissioner whose signature appeared on Tavana’s warrant.
Apparently the moment had arrived.
Bell called from downstairs.
“Mrs. Bellamy, I am looking for Deputy Marshal Boon Haleran.”
Tavana whispered, “Does he know you are here?”
“He shouldn’t.”
Bell continued.
“He may be traveling with five fugitives.”
My hand moved toward my revolver.
Tavana shook her head.
“No confrontation.”
I knew she was right.
The papers mattered more than an arrest.
We slipped through the window onto a narrow back awning and climbed down behind the boardinghouse.
As we crossed the alley, I heard Bell speaking through the open window.
“He is confused, Mrs. Bellamy.”
Something about the tone stopped me.
“Deputy Haleran has suffered a severe personal shock.”
Tavana touched my arm, urging me onward.
Then Bell said the sentence that rooted my boots to the dirt.
“He believes his wife Abigail is alive.”
Mrs. Bellamy said nothing.
Bell continued gently.
“You must not encourage that delusion.”
Tavana stared at me.
I stared back.
How did Bell know what I had discovered only minutes earlier?
Then his next words answered that question and created a far worse one.
“Abigail Haleran died four years ago.”
A pause followed.
“And the woman calling herself Abigail now is an impostor.”
We made it to the cottonwoods without being seen.
But as Kane helped saddle the horses, Tavana handed Abigail’s letter back to me.
“What if Bell told the truth?”
I looked again at the familiar handwriting.
Four years of grief had taught me to want only one impossible thing.
Now that impossible thing might be waiting somewhere ahead.
Yet for the first time, I had to ask myself a question more frightening than whether Abigail lived.
If the woman writing those letters was not my wife, then who knew our marriage well enough to become her?
**–END OF PART 4–CLICK “NEXT” AT THE BOTTOM OF THE PAGE TO CONTINUE READING**
✓ S. Gary Kenneth
There are facts a man rejects because they are impossible, and there are facts he rejects because accepting them would require him to become someone else. For me, Abigail belonged to the second kind….