Part 3: One Bed, One Blizzard and the Secret My Brother Left Behind 039
By sunrise, the storm had spent most of its fury.
Snow still fell between the pines, but it came softly now, settling across the mountains in a silence so complete that even the cabin seemed reluctant to make a sound.
Caleb stood outside with a shovel, clearing a narrow path toward the woodshed.
I watched through the frost-clouded window while drinking coffee that tasted exactly as terrible as Thomas had once described it.
For reasons I could not explain, that made me trust Caleb more.
A liar might have improved his coffee over seventeen months.
Caleb apparently had not improved anything.
When he came inside, snow clung to his beard.
“You’re staring,” he said.
“I was reconsidering my opinion of my brother.”
“Because?”
“He described your coffee as muddy water strained through a boot.”
Caleb removed his gloves.
“He was being generous.”
I laughed before I could stop myself.
The sound felt strange in my chest.
I had not realized how little I had laughed since Thomas disappeared.
Caleb looked at me with an expression I could not read.
Then he turned away and began packing food into a canvas bag.
“We leave in an hour.”
“For Marker Seventeen?”
“Yes.”
“How far?”
“Three miles.”
“That hardly seems far.”
“In June, no.”
“And today?”
“Today you will discover why sensible people do not measure mountain travel in miles.”
He found an old pair of wool socks and placed them beside my boots.
The socks were far too large.
“So your plan is to prevent me from freezing by dressing me as you?”
“My plan is to prevent you from losing toes.”
“Less fashionable.”
“More useful.”
The simplicity of our exchange unsettled me.
Only hours earlier I had believed him heartless.
Now I was pulling on his socks and drinking his dreadful coffee while he checked my boots to make certain they had dried properly.
I wondered how often human beings were mistaken about one another simply because they had met at the wrong moment.
We left shortly after sunrise.
The world beyond the cabin seemed almost impossibly bright.
Snow covered the ground in deep folds, and sunlight broke through moving clouds, flashing against the white slopes until I had to shield my eyes.
Caleb walked ahead, breaking trail.
He carried the Winchester across his back, though I suspected it was more habit than necessity.
For the first mile, neither of us spoke.
I concentrated on placing my boots where his had been.
Even with that advantage, snow reached nearly to my knees in places.
“You do this for enjoyment?” I finally asked.
Caleb glanced over his shoulder.
“No.”
“Then why live here?”
“Cheap rent.”
I stopped.
He looked back at me.
“Was that a joke?”
“I’ve been told I make them occasionally.”
“You should warn people.”
“It ruins the effect.”
We continued uphill.
Eventually the trees thinned, and a broad white valley opened before us.
Dark ridges rose on either side.
Far below, a frozen creek curved between stands of aspen.
Caleb pointed toward a weathered post emerging from the snow.
“That is Marker Twelve.”
“What are the markers for?”
“Old survey line.”
“Thomas’s?”
“Ours.”
The word felt important.
Caleb continued.
“Years ago, the county wanted a winter freight route mapped between Leadville and several smaller camps.”
“And you and Thomas surveyed it.”
“We helped.”
“What was the lie?”
His pace slowed.
“You’ll understand at Seventeen.”
“I would prefer understanding before my legs freeze.”
He almost smiled.
Then his expression became serious again.
“Thomas and I made a mistake.”
“What kind?”
“We marked a route before we had properly walked it.”
I frowned.
“Why?”
“Pride.”
That answer surprised me.
Caleb stopped beside a pine bent under snow.
“We were younger than we thought we were.”
“That sounds impossible.”
“It is common in men.”
I smiled despite myself.
“We had been told the western ridge was unsafe after heavy snow,” he continued.
“Thomas insisted the warning came from men who simply did not want competition on the route.”
“And you agreed.”
“I wanted to.”
“Why?”
“Because being wrong is easier when someone you like is wrong beside you.”
The honesty of it held me silent.
“We put Marker Seventeen higher than we should have,” he said.
“Then we discovered the slope beyond it was unstable.”
“Did anyone get hurt?”
“No.”
Relief loosened something inside me.
“We corrected the route before freight companies used it, but Thomas could never forget that we had pretended certainty when we had none.”
“So when he wrote where we first lied, he meant this place.”
“Yes.”
“Why would he return here?”
“That is what I have wondered for seventeen months.”
The final climb was steep.
Caleb offered his hand twice.
I refused the first time.
I accepted the second.
His palm was rough and warm through the glove.
He did not pull me upward.
He merely steadied me while I climbed.
The distinction mattered.
Marker Seventeen stood on a narrow shelf beneath a granite outcrop.
The post leaned badly.
Someone had carved a deep X into the wood.
Caleb brushed snow from the base.
“Thomas did that.”
“When?”
“The last time I saw him.”
My breath caught.
“You were here with him?”
“Yes.”
“You told me he left town after seeing a doctor.”
“He did.”
“But you saw him afterward.”
“Once.”
Anger stirred again.
“You seem to have a remarkable talent for telling the truth in pieces.”
Caleb accepted the accusation without protest.
“I was afraid the whole truth would sound like an excuse.”
“For what?”
He looked toward the distant mountains.
“For letting him leave alone.”
There it was.
The burden he had been carrying.
Not a crime.
Not a hidden cruelty.
A decision.
“I came here one morning and found Thomas sitting beside the marker,” Caleb said.
“He looked exhausted.”
“What did he tell you?”
“That he was leaving.”
“Where?”
“He would not say.”
“Did you try to stop him?”
“For three hours.”
I imagined Thomas sitting stubbornly in the snow while Caleb argued beside him.
The picture was so easy to see that my chest hurt.
“What did he say?”
“That he had spent his entire life being responsible for everybody except himself.”
I looked down.
Thomas had raised me after our mother died.
He had been twenty-one.
I had been thirteen.
He had learned to cook badly, mend buttons worse, and stretch every dollar until it squealed.
I had never asked whether he wanted that responsibility.
Children rarely asked such questions.
They simply trusted love to continue functioning.
“He was sick,” Caleb said softly.
“He knew it?”
“Yes.”
“And he still left alone.”
“Yes.”
“Why?”
“He said because if he told you, you would come.”
“He was right.”
“I know.”
“I would have taken care of him.”
“I know.”
The anger left as quickly as it had come.
In its place was something more painful.
Thomas had known me well enough to predict my love.
He had also feared what my love would cost me.
Caleb knelt beside the marker.
“There should be something here.”
I watched him clear snow with his gloved hands.
“You knew?”
“No.”
“But the note—”
“Thomas liked hiding things in obvious places.”
“That is contradictory.”
“Thomas was contradictory.”
“That is true.”
Caleb dug beneath a flat stone.
His fingers struck metal.
We looked at one another.
He lifted a narrow tin box from the frozen earth.
My heartbeat became painfully loud.
The lid had rusted along one edge.
Caleb handed the box to me.
“You should open it.”
My hands trembled as I worked the clasp.
Inside were several folded pages wrapped in oilcloth.
There was also a brass key.
I recognized Thomas’s handwriting immediately.
The first page was dated eighteen months earlier.
Eliza will hate this.
I stopped reading.
Caleb looked away, giving me privacy without leaving.
I continued.
Eliza will hate this, and she may be right to hate it, but I have decided that I will not ask her to spend another year arranging her life around mine.
She was thirteen when Mother died, and I became so accustomed to being needed that I never noticed the moment she stopped needing a guardian and became a woman with plans of her own.
She wants to teach.
She wants to see places that have no memory of our family.
She pretends otherwise because she thinks gratitude is the same thing as obligation.
It is not.
My eyes blurred.
I wiped them angrily.
Thomas had known.
I had once been offered a position assisting at a school outside Denver.
I had refused because he was preparing to leave for Colorado.
I told him I preferred to remain near family.
He had believed me.
Or perhaps he had pretended to.
I read on.
The doctor says the mountain air may help, but he also says I need rest that no surveying crew can provide.
I have arranged to go somewhere quiet.
I will write to Eliza when I know whether I am improving.
Rowan believes this is cowardice.
He is probably right.
The next paragraph had been written in darker ink.
If something happens before I write to her, I have asked Miriam Bell to hold the key enclosed here.
The box it opens contains the letters I could not send and the name of the place where I went.
I looked at the brass key.
“Mrs. Bell,” I whispered.
Caleb nodded.
“Leadville postmistress.”
“She wrote to me.”
“When?”
“Three weeks ago.”
His surprise was genuine.
“She wasn’t supposed to?”
“I don’t know what Thomas asked her to do.”
I turned the page.
The final lines had been added later.
Caleb moved closer when he saw my expression.
“What is it?”
“There is another date.”
“How much later?”
“Six weeks.”
I read aloud.
I came back to Marker Seventeen today because I realized something during the night.
The first lie Rowan and I told here was not that we knew the mountain.
It was that being wrong meant we had failed completely.
Maybe that is why I have been unable to tell Eliza I am afraid.
Maybe I would rather disappear as the brother who always had answers than remain as a man who does not.
I stopped.
Snow slid softly from a branch behind us.
Caleb said nothing.
I forced myself to read the last lines.
If Eliza ever finds this, tell her I am sorry.
Then tell her she has no obligation to forgive me.
The truth must be hers before forgiveness can be.
Beneath those sentences, Thomas had written one final message.
Rowan, take her to Miriam.
The key is for Box 214.
She has the rest.
I folded the papers carefully.
Caleb remained beside me.
“You knew none of this?”
“No.”
“But you knew about Miriam.”
“Only that Thomas trusted her.”
I looked back toward the long trail descending between the pines.
“How soon can we reach Leadville?”
“If the road is passable, tomorrow.”
“Then we go tomorrow.”
Caleb nodded.
I put the journal pages back into the tin.
One slipped from my fingers.
It landed facedown in the snow.
When I lifted it, I saw writing on the reverse side.
Only one sentence.
The ink had been pressed so hard into the paper that Thomas had nearly torn it.
I read it twice before understanding the words.
Then I handed it to Caleb.
His face drained of color.
Thomas had written:
If Eliza reaches Box 214, she will learn why I was never trying to come home.
**–END OF PART 3–CLICK “NEXT” AT THE BOTTOM OF THE PAGE TO CONTINUE READING**
✓ S. Gary Kenneth
By sunrise, the storm had spent most of its fury. Snow still fell between the pines, but it came softly now, settling across the mountains in a silence so complete that even the cabin seemed reluctan…