✓ LifeofMyStory

PART 2: The Secret Between Us 035

Posted by S. Gary Kenneth - November 22, 2026

Part 2 – The Secret Between Us

Spencer’s hands tightened around his armrests, and for a moment the cabin seemed to narrow around the four of us.

Gideon didn’t move closer or raise his voice.

He simply set the travel bags beside our seats and gave Spencer the same measured look he used when listening carefully to someone who had more to say.

“Judge Marsh,” Spencer said at last.

The title sounded different from his mouth now, stripped of its earlier amusement.

“Mr. Lowell,” Gideon replied.

Kendra’s gaze shifted between them.

“Wait,” she said, her smile fading. “You know each other?”

“We’ve met professionally,” Gideon said.

Spencer glanced toward the folded jacket beside my seat, then back to Gideon.

“So you’re the witness.”

“I am.”

The word landed with quiet weight.

Wren was still pressed against my side, one hand curled into the fabric of my cardigan.

She looked up at Gideon.

“Daddy, are we sitting with the man who was talking to Mommy?”

Gideon’s expression softened at once.

“We are, sweetheart,” he said. “But we’re all going to give one another room.”

Wren considered that.

“Okay.”

She turned toward Spencer with the open curiosity only a child could manage, then tucked her face against my shoulder again.

Spencer’s eyes followed her.

I could see the questions gathering behind them, but Gideon’s calm presence seemed to remind him of the setting, the witnesses, and the line he must not cross.

The flight attendant approached with a tray of drinks, and the ordinary clink of glass against silver seemed almost startling.

“Can I bring anyone something?” she asked.

“Water, please,” Gideon said.

“Orange juice,” Wren replied.

The flight attendant smiled and turned to Spencer and Kendra.

They both declined.

Once she had moved on, Gideon took the empty seat beside me.

He did not reach for my hand, though I knew he wanted to.

That small restraint meant more than a grand gesture would have.

He was making room for me to decide what I needed.

I gave him a brief look, and he answered with a quiet nod.

“Would you like to sit with me for a little while, Wren?” he asked.

Wren climbed into his lap without hesitation.

He settled her carefully against his chest, and she rested her cheek on his jacket as if she had found the safest place on the plane.

Spencer watched them.

There was something difficult to name in his expression.

It might have been envy, or regret, or the first understanding that the child he had never met did not feel like a blank space waiting for him.

She already had a father in the ways that mattered to her.

“Gideon,” I said quietly, “this is my daughter, Wren.”

Gideon brushed a loose curl from her forehead.

“I know, sweetheart.”

Then he looked across the aisle.

“Mr. Lowell, I want to be clear about something before this becomes uncomfortable for everyone.”

Spencer’s posture stiffened.

“The hearing tomorrow concerns your conduct as an attorney,” Gideon continued. “I’m there as a witness. I’m not deciding the matter, and I won’t use my position to influence it.”

“I didn’t ask you to,” Spencer said.

“No,” Gideon replied evenly. “But we are on a public flight, and I won’t discuss the hearing here.”

The words were firm without being sharp.

“I wouldn’t expect you to,” Spencer said.

“Good.”

Wren tilted her head, listening.

“Is there a hearing tomorrow?” she asked Gideon.

“There is,” he said. “It’s a meeting where people will talk about whether someone followed the rules in his work.”

“Oh.”

She seemed satisfied by that explanation and returned to the more pressing matter of her juice.

I watched Gideon help her with the little carton, his attention entirely on her, while something inside me loosened and tightened at once.

For six years, I had told myself that the past no longer had the power to surprise me.

But Spencer’s face across the aisle had opened a door I thought was sealed.

And behind that door stood the pregnant woman I had been, carrying a child while the man who had promised to love me forever walked away.

“Mommy,” Wren whispered, “is he a friend?”

“No,” I said, then softened my voice. “He used to be someone I knew very well.”

She gave that a moment’s thought.

“Like a neighbor?”

“Not exactly.”

Gideon looked at me, leaving the answer in my hands.

I wasn’t ready to tell Wren everything on a plane, with strangers only a few feet away.

“Can we talk about it later, when we have more privacy?” I asked.

“Sure.”

She leaned back against Gideon and began describing a cloud she had seen through the window before the curtain had come between us.

Her gentle chatter settled over the tension like a blanket.

Kendra turned toward Spencer and murmured something too low for me to hear.

He answered with a quiet shake of his head.

For once, he did not seem eager to perform for her.

I glanced at Gideon.

He had been my steady partner through sleepless nights, difficult decisions, and the thousand unremarkable moments that made a life.

He had never treated fatherhood as a favor or a role he could take on and put down.

From the first time Wren reached for his hand, he had met her with patience.

He had learned which stories she liked at bedtime, how she preferred her toast cut, and which songs could calm her when she was frightened.

He was her Daddy because he had loved her every day.

No hearing, old marriage, or biological fact could undo that.

“I’m sorry,” I murmured to him.

His eyes moved to mine.

“You have nothing to apologize for.”

“I should have told you Spencer was on the flight.”

“You didn’t know.”

“I mean the petition.”

His expression changed, though only slightly.

He shifted Wren so she could sit more comfortably.

“Would you like to tell me now?” he asked.

Spencer’s gaze lifted at the word petition.

I saw it, and I knew he had heard.

Gideon noticed too.

He did not ask me to continue, and he did not turn the moment into a confrontation.

He merely waited.

The truth had been sitting in my chest for weeks, heavy enough that hiding it from him had begun to feel like another kind of lie.

“Spencer recently asked for contact with Wren,” I said.

Gideon’s face remained composed, but his hand settled more securely around our daughter’s waist.

“Contact?” he asked.

“He says he wants to make amends.”

Spencer looked down at the armrest.

Kendra’s mouth tightened.

“I haven’t agreed to meet him,” I added. “I haven’t decided what I’ll do.”

Wren was absorbed in the view beyond the window and didn’t appear to hear.

Gideon kept his voice low.

“When did you receive the petition?”

“Three weeks ago.”

“And you didn’t tell me because you were still trying to understand what you wanted.”

“Yes.”

“I wish you’d felt you could bring it to me,” he said, “but I understand why you needed time.”

There was no accusation in his voice.

That almost made me feel worse.

“I didn’t want to make it real before I knew what to do.”

“It’s real whether you decide today or next month,” he said gently. “But you don’t have to decide on this flight.”

I looked down at my hands.

The petition had arrived in a plain envelope, its formal language making an old wound seem newly official.

Spencer claimed he wanted the chance to apologize and to know the daughter he had never met.

He had not asked for custody.

He had not demanded that Wren call him anything.

Still, every line had unsettled me.

The man who had left when I needed him most now wanted to step into the life I had built without him.

“What if his reasons aren’t as simple as he says?” I whispered.

“Then we take the time to find out.”

“And if he hurts her?”

“Then we protect her,” Gideon said. “Together.”

His certainty did not erase my fear, but it gave me somewhere to stand.

Across the aisle, Spencer sat very still.

He might have heard us, or he might have been absorbed in his own thoughts.

I couldn’t tell, and I didn’t ask.

The flight attendant returned with our drinks.

Wren thanked her, then asked Gideon whether the clouds below us might be made of cotton.

Gideon told her that they looked soft from a distance but were made of water droplets.

She accepted this as a fact worthy of careful consideration.

“What happens tomorrow?” I asked him.

“I give evidence about the professional matter,” he said. “The panel will hear what I observed and what I know. That’s all.”

“You won’t be deciding anything?”

“No.”

“Even though you’re a senior judge?”

“I have no authority over that hearing,” he replied. “And I wouldn’t use my position to affect it if I did.”

Spencer glanced at him again.

This time, he seemed to understand that Gideon was not offering a private warning or arranging a private favor.

There would be no shortcut.

No private conversation in the corridor that could alter the truth.

“I wouldn’t want special treatment,” Spencer said.

“Then we agree on something,” Gideon replied.

The plane shuddered lightly as it passed through a patch of turbulence.

Wren reached for my hand.

I held it while Gideon kept his arm around her shoulders, the three of us joined by a simple chain of touch.

When the seat belt sign came on, the cabin crew moved through the aisle, asking passengers to remain seated.

Kendra stared at the safety card in front of her.

Spencer leaned back and closed his eyes, though his jaw remained tense.

For several minutes, the plane carried us in a silence filled with engines and unspoken questions.

Wren broke it first.

“Mommy?”

“Yes, sweetheart?”

“Why did the man look at me like he knew me?”

My throat tightened.

Gideon’s gaze rested on me, steady but not directing.

I lowered my voice.

“He knows who you are, Wren.”

“From where?”

I brushed my thumb over her knuckles.

“Your biological father is Spencer.”

The words came out carefully, without drama.

Wren blinked.

“Is he the man over there?”

“Yes.”

She looked across the aisle.

Spencer had opened his eyes.

For a moment, he met hers, then looked away, as if he did not want to frighten her by staring.

Wren leaned closer to me.

“Is Daddy still my daddy?”

Gideon’s arm tightened gently around her.

“Yes,” I said. “Gideon is your Daddy, and nothing about this changes that.”

“Even if Spencer is my biological father?”

“Even then.”

She considered the answer, then leaned across Gideon to press a kiss to his cheek.

“I love you, Daddy.”

“I love you too,” he said, his voice rougher than before.

Wren returned to my side and rested her head against my shoulder.

She had taken in what she could and left the rest for later.

Across the aisle, Spencer’s eyes stayed on his hands.

I wondered what he had imagined when he petitioned for contact.

Perhaps he had pictured an eager child, or a clean apology, or the possibility of stepping into a place still waiting for him.

He had not seen the daily work that had made Wren feel safe.

He had not watched Gideon learn the words to her favorite bedtime song or sit beside her through a fever.

The life Spencer had left behind was not empty.

It was full.

Still, I could not ignore the petition forever.

Nor could I pretend that Wren’s questions would never grow more complicated.

The pilot announced that we would begin our descent in about twenty minutes.

Gideon looked toward me.

“Do you want me to take her through the airport while you collect your things?”

“I think I’d like us to stay together.”

“Of course.”

Spencer stood when the seat belt sign went off, then paused in the aisle as if considering whether to approach.

Gideon rose too, placing himself beside Wren without blocking her view.

Spencer’s eyes moved from Gideon to me.

“I didn’t know she was—”

He stopped himself.

I held his gaze.

“You knew I was pregnant when you left.”

His face tightened.

“I did.”

“Then you knew there might be a child.”

“I knew.”

The admission was quiet, but it carried none of the defense I had expected.

For a moment, his expression looked less calculating than tired.

“I’m not asking you to discuss anything here,” he said. “I understand what Judge Marsh said.”

“Gideon,” I corrected, before I could stop myself.

Spencer’s eyes shifted to him, then back to me.

“I understand what Gideon said.”

The correction felt small, but I noticed it.

So did Gideon.

He offered no response.

Spencer glanced toward Wren.

“I’m sorry I surprised you,” he said to her.

Wren stayed close to me.

“That’s okay,” she said politely.

Kendra had risen beside him, her expression difficult to read.

For a moment, I thought Spencer might ask to speak with me alone.

Instead, he stepped aside to let another passenger pass.

The moment dissolved into the bustle of bags, seat belts, and people preparing to disembark.

When we finally left the plane, Wren held one of Gideon’s fingers and two of mine.

The airport windows glowed with pale morning light.

Ahead of us, Spencer walked several paces behind Kendra, carrying no bag and saying nothing.

I was grateful for the distance.

I was also aware that tomorrow we would be in the same hearing room, facing a story none of us had finished telling.

At the baggage carousel, Gideon went to collect our luggage while Wren and I waited near a row of seats.

She rested her chin on my arm.

“Will Spencer come to our house?” she asked.

“Not unless we decide it’s a good idea.”

“Will I have to call him Daddy?”

“No.”

“Good,” she said. “I already have a Daddy.”

My eyes burned.

I kissed the top of her head.

“You do.”

Gideon returned with our bags and placed the smaller one beside Wren.

“Ready to go, sweetheart?”

She nodded and reached for his hand again.

As we turned toward the airport doors, I noticed Spencer standing near the far window.

He was alone now.

Kendra had disappeared into the crowd.

He held a thin envelope in one hand, its edges softened with age.

My steps faltered.

Spencer saw me looking.

For a second, he seemed unsure whether to speak.

Then he lifted the envelope slightly.

“This was returned to me,” he said.

Gideon’s posture changed, though he kept his voice calm.

“When?”

“Years ago.”

I stared at the worn flap, my name visible beneath a faded postal mark.

It was addressed to the apartment I had lived in after Spencer left.

“I tried once to write to you,” he said.

The envelope remained sealed.

I could not tell whether the letter inside contained an apology, an excuse, or something else entirely.

Spencer looked from it to me.

“I don’t know if you ever saw it.”

My fingers tightened around Wren’s hand.

“I didn’t.”

Wren looked up at me, sensing the change in my voice.

Gideon stayed close but said nothing.

I stared at my name on the old envelope and felt the past shift beneath my feet.

“What did you write, Spencer?”

“I don’t know,” he said. “I never opened it after it came back.”

Then his gaze dropped to the faded address.

“But someone had written a note on it, and I believed what it said.”

**–END OF PART 2–CLICK “NEXT” AT THE BOTTOM OF THE PAGE TO CONTINUE READING**

* * *

[NEXT: PART 3](https://puretales.idolsgift.com/blog/part-3-the-secret-between-us-035)

✓ S. Gary Kenneth

Part 2 – The Secret Between Us Spencer’s hands tightened around his armrests, and for a moment the cabin seemed to narrow around the four of us. Gideon didn’t move closer or raise his voice. He sim…

Leave a Reply