✓ LifeofMyStory

I found a $24,000 fence assessment on my doorstep two years after buying my Colorado

Posted by S. Gary Kenneth - November 21, 2026

I called Derek Shaw, the fence contractor, and explained that I was disputing an HOA assessment. After checking his files, he confirmed his entire job totaled $7,400, with no extra phases, cameras, or special security equipment. He agreed to provide written confirmation after consulting his bookkeeper.

Derek also remembered someone from the association asking for an editable copy of his invoice in October, supposedly because a file was corrupted. I recorded his account without assuming what anyone had done with that document. Nathan wanted facts that would hold up under scrutiny, not accusations that sounded satisfying.

I searched the Colorado business registry for Ridgecrest Advisory Group. It had been formed shortly before the fence approval date, and its registered manager was Graham Wexler, Preston’s cousin. That relationship raised a conflict-of-interest question, but it wasn’t proof that the consulting work was fictitious.

The HOA supplied no consulting report when I asked what Ridgecrest had delivered. Some project codes also appeared to have been updated after the original invoice dates. Nathan sent a preservation letter seeking the electronic approval history, backups, contracts, and edit logs.

Then Mary Ann called, shaken. She had checked the approval history and found minutes showing she attended the September 14 meeting. “I was at a cardiology appointment in Denver,” she said, “and the meeting was canceled.”

We met at a coffee shop on College Avenue. She brought her appointment confirmation, calendar, and the original cancellation email. The posted minutes claimed four directors attended and unanimously voted to put the entire assessment on my home, but Mary Ann said she had never cast that vote.

Nathan insisted we handle her access properly. Mary Ann reviewed records available to her as treasurer, without sharing passwords or entering anyone else’s account, and retained her own lawyer. She found the fence carried project code F119, and Preston had signed the Ridgecrest contract under an emergency spending provision.

There was no documented emergency requiring a fence beside my yard. Preston soon announced an investigation into unauthorized disclosures, and the HOA’s lawyer sent me a cease-and-desist letter. Nathan answered with a demand for preservation and an accurate accounting.

I noticed something else while rereading the records: the minutes claimed approval on September 14, but Shaw Fence and Gate’s invoice said the job was completed September 9. Audrey had been filming sunrise views for a painting and sent videos showing the crew arriving September 7 and Preston inspecting the work the following afternoon.

Nathan contacted vice president Russell Vance, whose name also appeared on the supposed unanimous vote. Russell met us at Nathan’s office and showed a flight confirmation placing him in Phoenix for his daughter’s volleyball tournament that day. He admitted he’d trusted Preston for years and often approved things without studying them.

Russell formally requested the vendor and payment setup records within his authority as a board officer. When they arrived, the missing $16,600 finally had names: $4,200 to Ridgecrest Advisory Group, $3,800 to Northgate Perimeter Solutions, $2,900 to Summit Compliance Partners, and $5,700 to Wexler Building Supply for landscape restoration.

I knew Preston’s family owned Wexler Building Supply. Derek said his crew had left the strip clean and had performed no landscaping afterward, and Audrey’s later footage showed the same bare patches of grass. Still, I needed to distinguish suspicious billing from expenses that could be supported by actual work.

Then Nathan placed three vendor setup forms beside one another. Ridgecrest, Northgate, and Summit listed different addresses and contacts, but all three directed payment to the same bank account. Preston’s electronic approval appeared on each form.

An August email thread supplied the reason the assessment might have been created. The management office warned Preston that the operating account was running short ahead of a December reserve study. Preston replied that an east-side special assessment would fill the gap and specifically identified my lot.

“She lives alone,” he wrote. “She has no connections on the board and she’ll pay to avoid trouble.” I read the words three times. He hadn’t merely underestimated my willingness to fight; he’d selected me because he thought I wouldn’t.

The email and payment forms raised questions about the flow of money, not a final finding of fraud. Nathan wanted an independent forensic accountant to trace the bank transactions and determine who ultimately controlled the vendors. I wanted the neighbors to see why those questions mattered.

Preston added an $850 administrative fee and sent a separate landscaping complaint about the side yard his fence had crowded. He also announced that Mary Ann was being placed on leave pending an internal review. I sat with her at her kitchen table until she stopped crying, and we agreed not to answer intimidation with rumors.

Our bylaws allowed owners holding at least ten percent of the 186 lots to demand a special membership meeting. We needed nineteen signatures. Audrey and I started knocking on doors in the snow, carrying copies of the documents Nathan had approved for sharing.

Eleanor Pruitt, an eighty-one-year-old retired teacher, showed me a $9,000 assessment she’d paid from her late husband’s life insurance for drainage work behind her home. She signed first among the people I visited that afternoon. By Tuesday, Audrey and I had twenty-six signatures, including two neighbors who’d laughed at Preston’s earlier meeting.

The meeting was scheduled for a Wednesday in mid-December, three weeks after my payment cleared. I built a binder with the invoices, canceled-meeting email, appointment and travel confirmations, contractor statement, video stills, vendor forms, and August correspondence. Nathan removed every conclusion the documents couldn’t yet support.

That night I laid the binder beside a cooling cup of tea and listened to the furnace. A dark SUV paused near my house, then drove away; I couldn’t identify its driver and made no accusation. Audrey saved footage from her porch camera, and knowing I wasn’t alone helped me finally sleep.

Part 3 More than a hundred residents crowded the clubhouse on meeting night. A neutral facilitator explained the petition and speaking rules, and Preston took the floor in a navy suit. He spent fifteen minutes discussing property values and community standards before suggesting that one disgruntled homeowner was wasting everyone’s money.

When my turn came, I set the binder on the front table and started with Derek’s signed confirmation. The fence cost $7,400, not $24,000. Then I placed the canceled September 14 meeting notice beside minutes claiming a unanimous vote.

Mary Ann stood and said she’d been in Denver for a medical appointment that day. Russell stood next and said he’d been in Phoenix. Both stated plainly that they hadn’t cast the votes attributed to them, and nobody laughed this time.

I showed the extra charges and Audrey’s dated footage of Preston inspecting the completed fence before the supposed approval. Eleanor held up her $9,000 drainage assessment. Three more residents raised notices from earlier years, and I could see people looking at their neighbors instead of the screen.

Finally I asked Preston to turn to the last page. It showed the three vendor setup forms routing payments to one bank account, each approved under his electronic signature, followed by his August email naming me as someone who would pay rather than cause trouble. Preston stared at the paper, then looked at Mary Ann and Russell.

He called the records misleading and said he wouldn’t dignify the meeting by remaining. The facilitator noted his departure and continued under the bylaws. I watched him leave without feeling the satisfaction I’d imagined; I mostly felt tired and relieved that the room had finally seen the evidence.

The homeowners voted overwhelmingly to suspend Preston as president, commission an independent forensic audit, freeze further payments to the four vendors, and refer the findings to the Larimer County District Attorney’s Office. Russell resigned as vice president and promised to cooperate. Mary Ann was reinstated as treasurer, and people stood to applaud her.

Afterward, neighbors came to me with old assessments and apologies. Doug Harmon, one of the men who’d laughed, said he’d followed the crowd because he didn’t want to stand out. I told him that what he did next mattered more than that one laugh.

The forensic audit took four months. It reported more than $180,000 in payments over roughly six years from association accounts to entities connected to Preston and his cousin, often associated with special assessments charged to homeowners who lived alone, were elderly, or had recently moved in. The findings were referred for investigation rather than treated as a courtroom conviction.

The association’s insurer and new board pursued recovery. The district attorney’s office opened a criminal investigation, which remained ongoing when I last heard, and Ridgecrest, Northgate, and Summit dissolved within weeks of the meeting. Preston sold his home that summer; I never saw him leave.

The new board rescinded my assessment as improperly approved and refunded the full $24,000, the $850 fee, and my legal expenses. Eleanor received her $9,000 back too. She called to tell me she was finally planning to visit her sister in Oregon, and her happiness meant more to me than any speech at the clubhouse.

Final The fence came down in April. Derek’s crew removed it without charging the community again, and I stood beside Audrey watching the utility corner become accessible. For the first time in months, I could walk along my own side yard without thinking about an invoice.

Several neighbors asked me to run for HOA president. I declined, but I joined the finance committee, where I could examine invoices and ask how approvals were documented before money moved. I wasn’t interested in replacing one unquestioned authority with another.

People ask whether I was frightened. I was, especially after transferring nearly all the savings I’d worked so hard to build. I had moved to Blackstone Ridge hoping for peace after years of investigating questionable financial claims, and I nearly let Preston convince me that peace required silence.

He saw a woman living alone, fixing her own gutters, and assumed she would pay to avoid embarrassment. What he missed was that I’d spent fifteen years following money through records that were much harder to understand than his fence invoices. Even so, I couldn’t have done it alone; Audrey, Mary Ann, Russell, Derek, Eleanor, Nathan, and the other homeowners each helped establish a piece of the truth.

I still keep the original $24,000 notice and the refund confirmation together in a folder. They remind me that an impressive title and a polished letterhead don’t answer a simple question: where did the money go? Sometimes the answer is already in the records, waiting for someone to read every page.

THE END. I’ve shared the complete story, and I truly hope it touched your heart. If this story moved you, please , like, and share the post. Thank you for reading! ❤️

✓ S. Gary Kenneth

I called Derek Shaw, the fence contractor, and explained that I was disputing an HOA assessment. After checking his files, he confirmed his entire job totaled $7,400, with no extra phases, cameras, or…

Leave a Reply